Podcast #28: Explore Atlas Shrugged, Session 11

 Posted by on 16 February 2010 at 8:00 am  Podcasts
Feb 162010

For Monday’s episode of Philosophy in Action Radio, I posted a preview of my podcast and study questions for “Explore Atlas Shrugged, Session 11.”

The online version of Explore Atlas Shrugged – meaning, all 20 sessions of podcasts and study questions, plus other resources – can be purchased for just $20. The written materials are also available from Amazon in paperback and kindle formats, and purchasers of those editions pay just $10 for access to the podcasts. For more information, including previews of other sessions, visit Explore Atlas Shrugged.

Session 11 of Explore Atlas Shrugged covers:

  • Part 2: Chapter 9: The Face Without Pain or Fear or Guilt
  • Part 2: Chapter 10: Sign of the Dollar

Preview the Podcast

Listen or Download:

Preview the Study Questions

Note: The pagination of the hardcover, softcover, and kindle editions differs from that of the small mass market paperback. The study questions cite only the pagination from the larger editions. I don’t recommend using the mass market paperback.

Part 2: Chapter 9: The Face Without Pain or Fear or Guilt

Section 1 (633-648)

Francisco d’Anconia speaks to Dagny Taggart in her apartment after her first day back at work at Taggart Transcontinental. Hank Rearden enters using his key, and an explosive confrontation between Hank and Francisco ensues. After Francisco departs, Dagny and Hank have violent sex. A letter arrives from Quentin Daniels announcing that he has quit his work on the motor.

Core Questions

  • What is Dagny’s state of mind when she returns to work after the tunnel disaster? How and why has her attitude toward her work changed? (633-4)
  • What are the major points of agreement and disagreement between Dagny and Francisco, particularly regarding “the man of ability”? What factors influence each’s reasoning and decision? Should Dagny accept Francisco’s views? Why or why not? (635-7)
  • How does Francisco learn that Hank is Dagny’s current lover? What does that revelation mean to Francisco – and why? (638-9)
  • What does Hank think of and feel for Francisco now? Why? How does Francisco respond – and why? (638-40)
  • Why does Hank slap Francisco? What is Francisco’s reaction to that? What does Hank learn and feel afterwards? (640-1)
  • Why does Dagny tell Hank that Francisco was her first lover? What is Hank’s reaction – and why? How and why is their sex afterwards so violent? How is Hank different afterwards? (641-3)
  • Why has Quentin Daniels quit? Is he right or wrong to do so? What does Dagny want him to do instead – and why? (644-5)

Extra Questions

  • How is Dagny’s attitude toward and relationship with Francisco changed by her knowledge that his goal is to destroy d’Anconia Copper? (634-8)
  • What is Francisco’s purpose when he speaks to Dagny at the cabin? What is Dagny’s response to that purpose? (634-5)
  • What is Francisco’s response to Dagny’s settled decision to continue working at Taggart Transcontinental? What does that reveal about his values? What might he do instead? Would that be better or worse? (635, 637)
  • Why does Dagny think that she might need to beg Francisco’s forgiveness at some point in the future? Why is she committed to her present course despite that? What does that reveal about her values? (636)
  • What does Francisco mean when he warns Dagny that they are enemies? What are the practical implications of that? Is he right? (636-7)
  • How does Dagny learn that Francisco is not acting alone? What is the significance of that to her? (637)
  • What does Francisco mean when he says that he will always wait for Dagny? Should he do so? (637-8)
  • What does Dagny think, feel, and say in response to the confrontation between Hank and Francisco? Why? (638-41)
  • Why does Hank suspect that Francisco intends to double-cross Dagny? Is that a fair accusation? (638)
  • Why does Hank say that Francisco is “worse than the looters”? Given what Hank knows of Francisco, is that fair? (640)
  • Why does Dagny think that Francisco’s restrained response to Hank’s slap is Francisco’s “greatest achievement”? (640-1)
  • Why does Dagny feel pity for both men after Francisco departs? (641)
  • Why does Hank feel that sex with Dagny is “the act of victory over his rival and of surrender to him”? (642)
  • Why does Dagny want Hank more than ever in their sexual encounter? What does it mean to her? (642-3)
  • What is Hank’s attitude toward Dagny and Francisco after sex with Dagny? Why? Why does Dagny think that everything has been said but just remains to be acknowledged? (643)
  • Why didn’t Francisco ever tell Hank about his affair with Dagny? What does Hank learn from that? (643)
  • What does Quentin Daniels represent in the earlier debate between Dagny and Francisco about her choice to return to work at Taggart Transcontinental? How do Daniels’ own views shed light on that debate? (644-5, 635-7)
  • What does Dagny convince Daniels to do once she speaks to him on the telephone? Why is that so important to her? (646-7)
  • What does Dagny’s departure to Utah reveal about her priorities? (647-8)
  • What does Hank want to tell Dagny as she departs? Why doesn’t he? (648)

About Explore Atlas Shrugged

Explore Atlas Shrugged is a series of 20 sessions of podcasts and study questions by me, philosopher Dr. Diana Hsieh. Each session covers about 65 pages of the novel, organized chapter-by-chapter and section-by-section. The podcasts are an in-depth look at the events, characters, and ideas from that portion of the novel. The whole series contains over 22 hours of lively and engaging discussion in podcast form. The study questions will help you better understand the novel on your own – or help you lead an engaging reading group. The series includes over 1400 questions, organized into “core” and “extra” categories.

You can preview the full series of podcasts and questions, as well as purchase access for just $20, here: Explore Atlas Shrugged. You can also purchase the series below.

Also, the written materials are available from Amazon in paperback and kindle formats, and purchasers of those editions pay just $10 for access to the podcasts.

Purchase Explore Atlas Shrugged

Access to the online version of Explore Atlas Shrugged costs just $20. It’s half off – just $10 – for purchasers of the paperback and kindle editions of the book version. Also, if you contribute to Philosophy in Action’s Tip Jar via recurring weekly or monthly contributions (or the equivalent), please email me for free access.

Terms of Sale: (1) You may share the podcasts with members of your household, but not beyond that. (2) You may share the study questions with members of your household, as well as with participants in your online or in-person Atlas Shrugged Reading Group. (3) Do not ever post the podcasts or study questions in any public forum.

Items: Course: Explore Atlas Shrugged ($20)
Course: Explore Atlas Shrugged (Half Price Discount) ($10)
Note: This half-price discount is only available to purchasers of a paperback or kindle edition of Explore Atlas Shrugged. Please email me a screenshot or picture as proof.

Praise for Explore Atlas Shrugged

The response to Explore Atlas Shrugged has been overwhelmingly positive, including the following remarks:

I require students to read Atlas Shrugged in my introductory economics class. Dr. Hsieh’s Explore Atlas Shrugged podcasts were an essential tool to help communicate the novel’s lesson and hold effective class discussion. Do not attempt to teach the book without consulting the podcasts first!

— Bailey Norwood, Associate Professor, Department of Agricultural Economics, Oklahoma State University


Thank you, thank you, thank you, Diana – our GLO Atlas Reading Group is going so very well. We have about 12-13 people attending, and it is truly the most fun we’ve had in a long time. So much rewarding fun comes out of your ideas and organization. Can’t thank you enough for your efforts!!!


I just wanted to send you a quick note and thank you for your efforts on Explore Atlas Shrugged. As part of the Charm City Objectivists Society we used your questions and podcast to help kick off our reading group yesterday for session one. We had epiphanies all around the table from someone who is a firm student of Objectivism to a person who had read Atlas Shrugged but is new to Objectivism. I know that neither Ray (our moderator) or myself could have undertaken this kind of thing without the wonderful resource you have created. You have helped me make a difference in my community and I thank you for it.


The other day, I began listening to your Explore Atlas Shrugged podcasts. I have read and listened to the book several times, but it has been admittedly too long since the last time. Although I can not adequately express how much experiencing your podcasts has meant to me and the extent to which they have reinvigorated me, I did want to thank you…Thank you.

About Philosophy in Action Radio

Philosophy in Action Radio focuses on the application of rational principles to the challenges of real life. It broadcasts live on most Sunday mornings and many Thursday evenings over the internet. For information on upcoming shows, visit the Episodes on Tap. For podcasts of past shows, visit the Show Archives.

Philosophy in Action's NewsletterPhilosophy in Action's Facebook PagePhilosophy in Action's Twitter StreamPhilosophy in Action's RSS FeedsPhilosophy in Action's Calendar

Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha